Comments on: The Thinspiration Problem: Where Do Fashion Bloggers Factor In? https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/ Independent Fashion Bloggers Mon, 19 Feb 2024 12:42:06 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.6.2 By: Amanda https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-392138 Tue, 23 Jun 2015 13:34:28 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-392138 I think this is a huge issue. There are so many bloggers/famous Instagram girls out there who are WAYYYY too skinny– no doctor would tell them that they are healthy. Yet they have amassed hundreds of thousands of followers who worship their figure and wardrobe and entire lifestyle. Pictures don’t have to be labeled “pro anorexia” to be supporting a super skinny body image and anorexic behaviors. By continuing to follow girls like @somethingnavy, we as an audience are encouraging girls to eat less and less to achieve this kind of body. Girls are still obsessed with idolizing girls who have perfect hair, huge thigh gaps, and 13-year-old bodies. It’s like we live in a society of high school culture that never ends. And everyone seems to think it’s okay, which is the depressing part.

]]>
By: CJ https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-83419 Thu, 14 Mar 2013 04:11:00 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-83419 You know what I would like? To never hear or see “real women/girls” ever again. We are all real. Round, curvy or thin.

]]>
By: Vintage Pixie in Denim https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-51649 Tue, 08 May 2012 00:49:56 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-51649 I get a bad feeling everytime I see too thin people. I always look for content everywhere, and I think that everyone is effected slightly when we see these too skinny girls. Starving yourself is just not the way to go. I have friends with all different types of physics and to me they all look beautiful. The only question I ask them is “do you feel beautiful” or “do you feel healthy” and if they say no that’s when we have a problem, not if they are stick thin.

The most important thing, I think, is to be aware of all of the harm that social media sends out there, and as a community I think that we should embrace girls of all body types so that everyone feels good about themselves, and healthy in their lifestyles.

]]>
By: Emily Ulrich https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-50452 Tue, 01 May 2012 23:18:54 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-50452 It’s certainly difficult to be so involved in an industry and outlet oneself without having some regard for competing body image. that being said, when I look to other bloggers for inspiration, I don’t necessarily prefer one body type over another. For me, merit goes to creativity and style.

I think the internet can be a helpful tool for aspiring to better health, but (as with anything) extreme exploitation of it can be harmful.

While I appreciate and commend these sites for addressing the issue, I can’t help but feel like girls with these distorted perceptions and misguided goals will only continue, just under different means. And you never can tell which is more dangerous.

]]>
By: Katrina https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-50316 Tue, 01 May 2012 01:55:11 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-50316 As much as I`m not happy about this, I must however agree – the real womans body is underrepresented in the blogging community.

Blogs like Vintage Virgin, Native Fox and Atlantic Pacific come first to mind when it comes to tipping the scale of most popular fashion blogs. And even though girls like Nadia Aboulhosn have a certain crowd of followers too, I can`t help but wonder where in all this is the real girl? The girl who might not be a size zero, OR have the body of a plus size model? Where is the girl next door?

This topic is quite personal to me as I`v struggled myself to fit in to one of these frames. Being an average size 14 (UK) I clearly do not fit in to the image of a modern day thinspo beauty queen, however am also somewhat rejected by the plus size industry – as I am not particularly plus sized. I am just a regular woman (statistically speaking in the UK for example). I have been told that I have a pretty face and am photogenic, as well as tall and proportional – yet if I`d wish to make a career for myself in the modelling industry I`d either have to loose half of my body mass (to be a size of a normal model), or gain one fourth of it (to be considered as a plus size model).

Yet what bothers me the most is not even the fact that I, or women and girls like the average sized me that I am, are underrepresented in the fashion world (because let`s face it, we might as well get used to it already) – it is the fact that we seem to be not so popular in the blogging community. Which is a community mainly consisting (again, statistically speaking) of normal girls, like me and you. The girls next door. We are what make the community. We are the ones who run blogs of our own (filled with images of our normal selves), yet choose to make popular the blogs representing either sides of two extremes of body images: overly thin or overly curvy. It seems we ourselves disqualify OURSELVES from the blogging scene! And that is truly scary (compared to the fashion industry which is mostly driven by money and capitalism when it tries to drill in to us the ‘acceptable’ frame of a womans body, which in comparison with me is either the too skinny one, or the overly curvy one).

>’.'<

]]>
By: Asia Monique https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-50313 Tue, 01 May 2012 00:41:24 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-50313 Yes. I do believe that real women are not represented in the fashion world. As they are now in a sense starting to be showcased, they consider a little “hip action” to be “plus size” and we know that is not the case. Either way, I like the stand that the social media world has begun to take on the negative effects eating disorders have, especially on the younger generation, as they look to what is the latest trend, in fashion and beauty. Great article as well. -Xo

]]>
By: jamie https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-50315 Mon, 30 Apr 2012 22:31:09 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-50315 I think the point that is being missed here is that the girls who share these images, or promote a pro-ana lifestyle usually have a number of other issues, which leads to controlling what they eat because that’s the only thing that they can control. While sharing the images between these girls can further fuel their issues, I don’t think that banning these images will stop these kinds of disorders from happening.

And I have to say I agree on the comments about real girls. Just because a girl is bigger, doesn’t make her any more real than someone who is naturally thin.

]]>
By: Mandy https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-50280 Mon, 30 Apr 2012 18:40:14 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-50280 With all due respect, this doesn’t seem to be an issue amongst bloggers of color in regards to black and hispanic bloggers. It is pretty sad though….

]]>
By: Julia Amodt https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-50271 Mon, 30 Apr 2012 17:47:38 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-50271 I think now more than ever real girls are being represented, especially on fashion blogs. The magazines have always shown the coveted body shape, but fashion bloggers are usually regular people without extreme workout regimes, makeup and hair stylists. Society forgets those details and we idolize models or celebrities with perfect bodies but even their “look” as a whole. Blog pictures tend to not be super Photoshopped, so we as readers relate to them. Since Fashion blogging is becoming more important in the industry, hopefully it will change our view of what’s considered “beautiful”.

]]>
By: Ana Carneiro https://heartifb.com/the-thinspiration-problem-where-do-fashion-bloggers-factor-in/#comment-50097 Sun, 29 Apr 2012 18:12:00 +0000 https://heartifb.com/?p=18297#comment-50097 Hot Topic, that’s for sure!
I’ve been reading some of the comments as well and here’s what I think:

More add campaigns, fashion magazines and, of corse, blogs, should indeed feature curvy women to whom most women can relate with.
However, and like other people have written, banning pro-anorexia sites off the net will not keep people from developing eating disorders, they will always find it elsewhere. But controlling them would be a start.
One thing that should never be controlled are the photos people share of themselves! For instance, I easily put on weight, but my friend Andreia looses weight when she’s under stressed and no matter how hard she tries to put on weight, she hardly ever does!

I have never, and will never, admire one blogger over the other because of their skinny appearance! In fact, one of the blogs I follow and love is The Cherry Blossom Girl, and it’s not all about her beautiful sets! One of the things that inspire me the most in her blog are the photos in a bathing suit or lingerie, because she’s curvy and I can relate to that!

]]>